Marquette Wire

McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

As+political+science+professor+John+McAdams+prepares+for+his+return+to+campus+after+winning+a+years-long+legal+battle+with+the+university%2C+Marquette+is+moving+to+reshape+the+policies+at+the+heart+of+the+issue.+Marquette+Wire+stock+photo.
Back to Article
Back to Article

McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

As political science professor John McAdams prepares for his return to campus after winning a years-long legal battle with the university, Marquette is moving to reshape the policies at the heart of the issue. Marquette Wire stock photo.

As political science professor John McAdams prepares for his return to campus after winning a years-long legal battle with the university, Marquette is moving to reshape the policies at the heart of the issue. Marquette Wire stock photo.

As political science professor John McAdams prepares for his return to campus after winning a years-long legal battle with the university, Marquette is moving to reshape the policies at the heart of the issue. Marquette Wire stock photo.

As political science professor John McAdams prepares for his return to campus after winning a years-long legal battle with the university, Marquette is moving to reshape the policies at the heart of the issue. Marquette Wire stock photo.

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






John McAdams, a former professor of political science at Marquette, was suspended indefinitely without pay in 2014 after writing a post on his blog criticizing a graduate professor by name who did not allow a student to discuss the topic of same-sex marriage during their class.

McAdams filed a lawsuit challenging the suspension, which was ruled against by a Milwaukee County judge last May. McAdams has been in the process of appealing the decision since then.

McAdams’ appeal is being considered by a Wisconsin Appellate Court, which concluded briefing for the case Monday. He has also petitioned the Wisconsin Supreme Court for bypass, which would allow the case to skip the court of appeals and go straight to the Wisconsin Supreme Court. The results of that petition are forthcoming.

If the appeal is successful, two outcomes are possible: The court could require Marquette to reinstate McAdams, or it could send the case back to a lower court for reevaluation. If his appeal succeeds and he is required to be allowed reinstatement, McAdams said he would return to the classroom.

McAdams said despite the case attracting significant first-amendment attention, it is really about Marquette’s breach of contract.

“The first amendment does not automatically apply to private schools, private schools can restrict speech,” McAdams said. “Marquette, however, has a clause in faculty contracts saying that faculty have all the free speech rights guaranteed under the United States Constitution.”

Rick Esenberg, president of the Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty and McAdams’ lawyer, said there are a number of reasons McAdams’ appeal could be successful, among them the precedent-setting nature of the suit regarding academic freedom.

“You cannot be forced to silence yourself because of the possibility that someone else will read what you say and behave irresponsibly,” Esenberg said. “The limit of your right to freedom of speech can’t be the worst possible reaction on the part of someone who reads your speech. “

Both McAdams and Esenberg said that the case is stronger because the faculty hearing committee involved in the decision to suspend him was not impartial. One of the faculty who sat on the committee had previously signed a petition against him but was not excused from the committee because of it, McAdams said.

Esenberg said Marquette’s use of a faculty hearing committee was inappropriate for this situation. [Marquette tries] to draw an analogy between the faculty hearing committee and a jury,” Esenberg said.

“That’s inappropriate in a case involving freedom of expression because freedom of expression is a right against majority sentiment.”

University spokesperson Brian Dorrington said in an email that this issue is about Marquette’s efforts to stand up for its students.

“We’ve maintained throughout this process that a personal attack on one of our students is simply unacceptable,” Dorrington said. “Dr. McAdams’ tenured peers on the Faculty Hearing Committee concluded, unanimously, that he breached his core duties as a Marquette professor when he used his blog needlessly and recklessly to harm a Marquette graduate student.”

McAdams expects to hear a decision on the case and the petition to the Wisconsin Supreme Court this month.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
About the Writer
Morgan Hughes, Executive Projects Editor

Morgan is the executive projects editor for the Marquette Wire. She is a senior studying journalism and political science. She was formerly the executive...

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

    Higher Education

    Former USA Today Editor in Chief Joanne Lipman visits campus

  • McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

    Higher Education

    Gov. Tony Evers goes ‘On the Issues’ at Marquette University Law School

  • McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

    Higher Education

    President of Jesuit Superiors of Africa and Madagascar speaks at Marquette

  • McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

    Higher Education

    Students struggle to balance school and work

  • McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

    Higher Education

    Unlearning Racism workshop open for students and faculty

  • McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

    Higher Education

    Nursing study gets published in Journal of American Medical Association

  • McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

    Higher Education

    Dean of College of Business Administration stepping down to take sabbatical

  • McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

    Higher Education

    Heather Hathaway named acting dean of the College of Arts & Sciences

  • Higher Education

    Online learning advances at Marquette

  • McAdams’ appeal decision forthcoming

    Higher Education

    MUSG considers changes to residence hall visitation policy

Navigate Right