Marquette Wire

CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Carlie_FINALTwo weeks ago, I wrote a column about my hope for the next leader of the Roman Catholic Church. I expressed my wish for a pope who could relate to the majority of the world’s Catholics who live in the developing world, who would take a no-tolerance stance on sexual abuse within the Church and who would be open to beginning a productive conversation about the ordination of women.

With the recent election of Pope Francis, some of my hopes may come to fruition, but others may still be nothing but wishes.

Francis, as the first pontiff to hail from Latin America, is someone who I believe will be acutely aware of the concerns of Catholics and people of other faiths living below poverty lines – and below the equator. He has promised to remember the poorer citizens of the world. In the choice of his name alone, he has already shown this commitment.

Francis of Assisi was a man dedicated to a simple life and to living both in service to and solidarity with the poor. He was a proponent of peace, forgiveness and hope. Francis sought to shed light on darkness and bring joy to those who had little.

The new pope has quite a job ahead of him, given the sexual abuse and corruption scandals that have plagued the Church in the past decades. If he is able to embody his namesake, he will place the lives of others far above his own comfort. He has promised to lead not only a church that is of and for the poor, but a church that is poor itself, following in the Francis’ footsteps, and that is monumental.

Francis of Assisi, however, did not work alone. One of his first followers and closest friends was Clare of Assisi. Clare was dedicated to the same simple lifestyle as Francis. She was the abbess of her own religious order, successfully defending and leading a group of women that still exists today. Clare and Francis assisted one another in spreading their message, and Clare even cared for Francis at the end of his life.

As can be seen in Clare’s, and many other holy women’s, examples women have a huge role to play in Catholicism. But as I stated in my last column, many of them feel ostracized by their faith. A reader pointed out in the online comments section of my last column that Pope John Paul II issued a statement saying women could never be recognized as priests in the Roman Catholic Church. Pope Francis and many other conservative Catholics agree with this statement. There are also, however, many in the Church who disagree.

It is not my wish that Francis reverse John Paul’s decree immediately and allow women to enter seminaries tomorrow. I understand that there is reasoning behind his thoughts, and I do not wish to undermine the importance of history and tradition. However, I was recently reminded of the true meaning of the word catholic: universal. I would hope a faith that prides itself on being a universal religious home could find a way to at least start a conversation about how better to welcome half the world’s population into its arms and leadership. Catholic leaders have made mistakes in the past, and Church teaching has shifted and changed over the centuries. There is no reason that should stop now.

Francis’ election was definitely momentous and historical. He is the first Jesuit pope, the first Latin American pope and the first to choose the name of this saint who devoted his life to the poor. He has also already shown his dedication to a new brand of church leadership, and for that I am excited. However, in order for him to fully move the universal church forward, I believe even more change is necessary if it is to survive in the 21st century. The Church has made changes in the past, and the clay is certainly not dry; it can still be reformed to better serve and understand its people.

Caroline Campbell is a senior in the College of Communication with a major in journalism and a minor in history. Email her caroline.campbell@marquette.edu.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

2 Comments

2 Responses to “CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis”

  1. 2010 Alum on March 20th, 2013 9:09 am

    Ms. Campbell, thank you so much for your reflections! As a current seminarian, I encourage you to continue a thoughtful examination into the theology supporting the Catholic priesthood. Jesus Christ, when He became incarnate of the Virgin Mary, assumed maleness in His person. When He established the holy priesthood at the Last Supper, He conformed His apostles to His very person. This was possible because of their shared maleness. What Bl. Pope John Paul II made clear is that the Church cannot ordain women because Christ did not ordain women. The Church can no more change the Sacrament of Holy Orders than it can change the Sacrament of Holy Eucharist. In the sacraments, both substance and form matter! A priest cannot consecrate Oreos and milk. A priest cannot absolve sins without saying the words “I absolve you.” Only one man and one woman may enter into the Sacrament of Matrimony. One is not baptized if they are not baptized with the Trinitarian formula (“I baptize you in the Name of the Father, and of the son, and of the Holy Spirit.”).

  2. Guest on March 20th, 2013 9:34 am

    Moreover, the Church is theologically is feminine (“Holy Mother Church”). The priest, upon his ordination, is wed to the Church (hence the name “Father”). It is important for us to acknowledge the differences between men and women and come to a greater appreciation for the respective feminine and masculine genius (“Have you not read that He who created them from the beginning made them male and female.” -Matthew 19:4)

    I am glad that you mentioned St. Clare of Assisi. While there are no women within the hierarchy, believing that women have no role within the Catholic Church. One only needs to look at the Catholic reverence for our Blessed Mother Mary! There are 100s of religious orders of women consecrated to Jesus Christ (more marital language!), including the Poor Clare Sisters, an order dedicated to the charisms of St. Clare.

    The Church will survive in the 21st century. Jesus promised us that the very gates of Hell will not prevail against Her (Mt. 16:18). Remember, we are not a Church of “conservatives” or “liberals.” We are a Church that promotes Truth as it is revealed by God.

    Many prayers for your continued work! AMDG

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    Archbishop Listecki discusses bankruptcy, Catholic education

  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    Provost search resumes with finalized committee

  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    MU team returns from RoboCup in Brazil

  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    New MU law poll shows Burke, Walker in dead heat

  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    Search committee formed to find new AD, vice president

  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    Bishop resigns as opus dean of College of Engineering

  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    MU grad nominated as ambassador to Russia

  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    Former MU star Diener joins men’s basketball staff

  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    Interim leaders offer insight at university address, forum

  • CAMPBELL: Reflecting on the selection of Pope Francis

    Editors' Picks

    MUSG allocates $37,000 to student organizations