Marquette Wire

HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism

Photo by Andrew Himmelberg

Photo by Andrew Himmelberg

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.

Email This Story

Nazis marched on American soil in August 2017. This is not a science fiction story or a nightmare. This was, and continues to be, the reality of American politics in our time.

White nationalists and advocates of genocide have become a part of contemporary political spheres. What about the countless victims of the Nazis all those years ago during World War II? Or the millions who laid down their lives to stop the spread of Nazism? It feels as if the American public has forgotten the evils we once fought so ardently to defeat in Europe. This is especially true of the demonization of Antifa, a movement dedicated to combating the rise of Nazi beliefs in America.

Antifa is not a formal organization, but rather a conglomerate of smaller groups and networks with similar views. These groups recognize the dangers of allowing the hateful teachings of racists, sexists, anti-Semites and Islamophobes to exist without direct opposition and actively stand in the way of that hate.

Youth movements have often been the breeding ground of fascism, from the punk scene of the 1980s to the dark corners of the Internet today. The rise of public support of fascist ideologies, often obscured by the more palatable name of “alt-right” ideas, has been a terrifying aspect of the Trump era.

While law enforcement in Charlottesville failed to quell the scare tactics and violence of the white nationalist protestors this past summer, Antifa supporters picked up the slack and fought back against their unchecked and vile hatred. After Alex Fields Jr., a Nazi marcher, drove his car through a crowd of counter-protesters and murdered Heather Heyer, President Donald Trump claimed there was “blame on both sides.” After a member of the alt-right very intentionally murdered someone brave enough to stand up to racism, the president of the United States still sought to place blame on the left.

This sort of complacency is not only passivity, it actively emboldens the actions of the alt-right. This lack of outright condemnation is read as thinly-veiled support by the supporters of these far-right movements. As Nazism is tolerated more and more, their bigotry becomes less and less of a “fringe ideology.”

This is evidenced in the creeping rise of their evil in more and more mainstream platforms over the past two years. Condemnation is only the first stage in the fight against fascism.

Some critics have dubbed Antifa groups the “alt-left,” styling them as the Nazis of the political left. This is an unfair comparison that reduces the meaning of their actions to senseless violence without purpose. The degree of their respective activities is also incomparable. Antifa protestors in North America have killed a whopping total of zero people, yet the rise of violence from alt-right groups such as “the Atomwaffen Division” and the Ku Klux Klan have gone under-reported by mainstream media. The “Atomwaffen Division” is a Nazi group who share their views over internet message boards, and are responsible for the murder of five people over the past year.

Despite the undeniable fact that Nazis are killing people and Antifa are not, article after article have been written about the supposed dangers of Antifa. These are not two sides of the same coin. If one group has routinely expressed their support of genocide and ethnostates, and has repeatedly committed acts of violence on the innocent, and the other is actively trying to prevent that very violence, the former is clearly the dangerous party.

The de-platforming of bigots such as Milo Yiannopolous and Richard Spencer has been shown to be incredibly effective, as Antifa have routinely protested their speaking events and exponentially reduced the turnout of their engagement. While traditional media outlets and platforms such as the New York Times and Twitter often give these hateful figures platforms to recruit further support, Antifa recognizes these hate groups as an issue that must be addressed and fought head-on, rather than entertained or outright ignored.

Fighting fascism is as American as apple pie and baseball. While the white nationalists and Nazis cower behind arguments regarding their free speech and the oppression of their ideas, Antifa is one of the movements in this country that sees them for the hate-filled and dangerous monsters they really are. The media’s demonization of Antifa is complicity in the spreading of these anti-American and dangerous ideas.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


5 Responses to “HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism”

  1. Eric on May 2nd, 2018 5:57 pm

    Antifa wouldn’t be “villainized” if they didn’t act like fascists hiding under the pretense of being “antifascist.” Try looking up the definition of “Fascist” and actually consider what it says and then ask yourself who it applies to in regards to their actions today. It’s not the “nazis” (quotes because the definition of that word has been so muddied it’s almost useless now… thanks….).

    Since you’re probably too lazy I’ll give you a few snipits:

    To borrow from Wikipedia fascism is “characterized by dictatorial power, forcible suppression of opposition and control of industry and commerce.” In other words, do what we say or we will use violence to suppress you (yup, Antifa does that). As for the controlling industry and commerce, well they love to brag about boycotts, destruction of local businesses they disapprove of, and generally do want to control industry and commerce by forcing it to be other than what it is currently. They want final say on what is or is not acceptable industry and commerce.

    “Fascists believe that liberal democracy is obsolete” (also wikipedia), yup they say that too.

    ”Fascism rejects assertions that violence is automatically negative in nature and views political violence, war and imperialism as means that can achieve national rejuvenation” Yup, that sounds like Antifa as well

    “One common definition of the term focuses on three concepts: the fascist negations (anti-liberalism, anti-communism and anti-conservatism); nationalist authoritarian goals of creating a regulated economic structure to transform social relations within a modern, self-determined culture; and a political aesthetic of romantic symbolism, mass mobilization, a positive view of violence and promotion of masculinity, youth and charismatic leadership.” The masculinity part is again something they would argue against but if “masculinity” is defined as aggression, risk taking, use of violence, and the other usual suspects, then the show fits.

    If it walks like a fascist, talks like a fascist, and acts like a fascist… it’s a fascist. Calling themselves “anti-fascists” doesn’t change the reality of their actions.

    Your lionization of Antifa is complicity in the spreading of these anti-American (or just anti-liberal democratic ) and dangerous ideas.

  2. Eric on May 2nd, 2018 5:59 pm

    Can’t edit, but also Nazis do indeed suck and the majority of people agree. However, just because Nazis suck that doesn’t mean everyone who is opposed to them is automatically “good.” It’s entirely possible (and in fact is the case) that both Nazis AND Antifa suck and should not be treated as “good” or worthy of respect.

  3. Dr. Necessitor on May 4th, 2018 12:04 pm

    The FBI estimates there are between 2,500 and 10,000 actual Nazis out of a US population of 330 million. Using the larger number, Nazis make up 0.00003% of the total population. Antifa isn’t just fighting and trying to silence Nazis, it’s also acting against regular Americans of all political stripes. In reality, Antifa is nothing more than a group of anarcho-Communist thugs and losers.

  4. Man with the Axe on May 23rd, 2018 9:22 pm

    If I decide you are a Nazi do I get to use violence against you?

  5. Jon Schuster on August 19th, 2018 7:03 pm

    The Nazi movement in this country has dwindled down to nothing. To devote all this effort and attention on such a minor area of our society is idiotic. If these five deaths affect your sensibilities so much then wouldn’t your focus be better spent on say the 50,000 people that die every year at the hands of drunk drivers? Or the estimated 300,000 that are expected to die from opiate overdose in the next five years. But those movement wouldn’t be nearly as cool as smashing windows and torching cars. Long live the COOL movements.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.

Navigate Left
  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    EDITORIAL: Residence hall policies for break periods alienate students

  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    HARTE: Early morning classes harmful to learning

  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    KORENICH: Prison health care reforms needed

  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    BEG: Continued use of N-word perpetuates consequences

  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    NITSCHKE: Linguistic diversity enriches US culture

  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    BEG: Trump reiterates dangerous anti-immigrant rhetoric

  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    HARTE: Lower drinking age proposals contain various risks

  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    EDITORIAL: Civic engagement not limited to voting booth

  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    BEG: Corporations must be held environmentally accountable

  • HARRINGTON: Antifa villainization underplays dangers of American fascism


    HIMMELBERG: Liberal arts education overshadowed by STEM programs

Navigate Right